This page has been created as "fair usage" entirely to allow assessment and
appreciation, by those concerned with the subject, of the unique
portrayal of transgenderism in young people in the article,
especially by young people affected themselves, their relatives, friends,
medical personnel, policy makers and academics. All copyrights are wholely
© 2003, New York Daily News, NYC, USA
|Harvey Milk, the nation's first gay high school, is
the subject of support and the object of protest. But the East Village school
is not backing down on trying to offer sports to its students
September 27, 2003
Gay high school
eyes level field
By MICHAEL O'KEEFFE
NEW YORK DAILY NEWS SPORTS WRITER
Harvey Milk wants to establish sports teams
in PSAL by next year
Like thousands of New York City kids, Kimberly Howard loves basketball and
dreams of playing on her high school team. The softspoken 17-year-old sips
on a Sprite in a downtown Starbucks and talks about practicing with her brothers
and sister on the court next to her Queens home.
"I played on teams when I was younger,"
says Howard. "But I've never had a chance to play on a high school team."
Howard acknowledges she's not just a
typical kid obsessed with hoops. Born male, Howard takes hormones to become
female, which, as she points out, raises a unique question:
"Will transgender students be able to
play on the girls' teams?"
PSAL officials might have to answer
that question soon: Howard's school,
Harvey Milk High, the nation's first state-accredited school for gay, lesbian,
bisexual and transgender students, hopes to field teams in the city's Public Schools
Athletic League as soon as September 2004, according to assistant principal Alan
"Eventually we need to be part of the
PSAL," says Nolan, who is just getting a physical education program started
at Harvey Milk. "There's a great interest from the students in competing
in basketball, volleyball and other
Gay advocates cheer Harvey Milk's decision
and say the school's sports teams will help do for homosexual high school
kids what Jackie Robinson did for African-Americans 50 years ago - break
"What a great lesson it would be for
a Harvey Milk kid to turn around and hit a three-point shot at the buzzer,"
says Cyd Zeigler of Outsports.com, a gay-oriented sports website. "Once you
get on the field and you see someone kick a field goal or make a great catch,
nothing else matters. Other kids will learn they're a lot more like them
than they thought."
"When you see a bunch of kids playing
basketball, it doesn't matter if they are black or white," agrees author
and activist Billy Bean, who came out after playing outfield and first base
with the Tigers, Dodgers and Padres from 1987 to 1995. "If you can play,
Nolan says Harvey Milk officials aren't
interested in pushing gay pride or any other agenda; they simply want to
give their students the same opportunities available to other city school
kids, including offering a supportive environment to learn the teamwork,
discipline and sense of achievement that sports can
Nolan welcomes the interest; he says
the school will need help with funding, coaching and facilities. "There's
a lot of goodwill outside the school we will tap into," he says. "I'm confident
we'll get the help we will need."
Like Jackie Robinson, the athletes at
the nation's first openly gay high school will have to be thick-skinned -
gay-bashing protesters came from as far away as California for Harvey Milk's
first day of classes - and Cardozo basketball coach Ron Naclerio foresees
parent protests and thinks some teams might even choose to forfeit games
with a gay team.
"They better have good security," adds
basketball recruiting expert Tom Konchalski. "They will take a tremendous
amount of abuse from fans."
But other high school sports officials
predict the controversy will fade quickly - and perhaps, they add, turn into
acceptance, or at least a reluctant
"All children, regardless of orientation,
should be able to participate in athletics," says Martin Jacobson, the athletic
director at Manhattan's Martin Luther King High School. "I would hope that
a coach would use a game against a team from a gay high school as an opportunity
to teach tolerance."
Harvey Milk High, founded in 1985 by
the non-profit Hetrick-Martin Institute, received $3.2 million from the city
Department of Education this summer to fund its transformation from a two-room
program with 50 students to a full-fledged high school that will ultimately
accommodate 170 kids. Nolan says 107 students are currently
Hetrick-Martin spokeswoman Lenette Dorman
declined to discuss plans for sports teams with the Daily News, saying school
officials have been overwhelmed by the intensive press scrutiny and are wary
of critical coverage.
But Nolan, in his first year as assistant
principal at the East Village school, agreed to discuss the physical education
curriculum he's developed and future plans for
Now that it's a state-accredited school,
Harvey Milk students are required to pass health and physical education classes,
Nolan says. School officials hope to use another downtown high school or
college gym for volleyball and hoops; until then, they'll continue to clear
the furniture from a class room where they'll conduct aerobics, yoga and
martial arts classes.
"Right now, we're adapting to the fact
there is no gym," Nolan says.
Harvey Milk caters to students who have
been emotionally or physically abused at other schools, where locker rooms
and gyms are prime real estate for bullies. For many Harvey Milk kids, gym
was a class to cut. Howard says the phys ed teacher at her old school told
her she didn't have to come to class. "It was like, 'We'll excuse you because
you're gay,'" Howard says. "'You don't even have to show
As a result, many of Harvey Milk's students
were gasping for air during their first phys ed classes, and Nolan says his
students still complain that he's too hard on them. But he's delighted that
those same kids are walking with a newfound swagger. "Their level of fitness
has increased tremendously in three weeks," he says. "They have strength
and flexibility they never had before. They're very proud of
A student advisory group has urged
administrators to expand the curriculum to include outdoor activities such
as camping, orienteering and kayaking, Nolan says. The students also want
intramural sports, and eventually hope to field teams that will compete against
other schools. According to Dorman, several students have expressed interest
in attending Harvey Milk but were reluctant to leave the sports teams they
currently play on.
Like any other school petitioning the
PSAL to compete in a new sport, Harvey Milk administrators will have to line
up coaches, practice and playing facilities, and funding for uniforms and
other gear. They'll also need to prove they have enough interested and eligible
students to field a team.
First-year squads in the PSAL start
out as "developmental" teams that play abbreviated schedules. If there are
no major problems at the end of the first season - forfeited games or financial
problems, for example - they're permitted to join the PSAL conference as
a full member the following
But while Harvey Milk may be ready for
sports, it's still unclear whether sports is ready for Harvey Milk. Homosexuality
is a non-issue for many people in business, entertainment, and politics -
even mainstream churches have accepted gays into leadership
And a handful of pro teams - including
the Atlanta Braves, Chicago Cubs, Minnesota Twins and the Los Angeles Sparks
of the WNBA - openly welcome gay fans, and there are many gay athletes competing
in individual sports. But in many other ways, there is no room in the wide
world of sports for gay athletes.
Major League Baseball, the NFL, NBA
and the NHL have never had an openly gay player, and there is a long list
of sports figures - Jeremy Shockey, John Rocker, Todd Jones, Reggie White,
Sterling Sharpe and Garrison Hearst, to name a few - who have embarrassed
their leagues and teams with anti-gay comments. Slurs get passed around
clubhouses and practice fields like bottles of Gatorade.
"My coach once said 'You all played
like faggots, except for Esera," says Esera Tuaolo, the former NFL defensive
tackle who made his sexual orientation public last fall. "I thought, 'If
only you knew.' The further I went into the closet, the further I fell into
Homophobia is especially prevalent at
the high school level, says Dan Woog, the soccer coach at Staples High School
in Westport, Conn., and the author of several books about gay issues in sports.
Kids want to fit in with the crowd; they don't want to be ostracized for
being different, he says, and athletes who have gay feelings or are not sure
of their own sexuality are often the biggest homophobes.
"The number of gay athletes in high
school sports is thought to be low, but I've always thought it was 10%, just
like in other parts of life," says Woog.
The pressure is tremendous: Gay students
are three times more likely to attempt suicide than other kids, according
to the National Mental Health Association, and have much higher dropout rates.
The pressure to stay in the closet, Woog says, contributes to substance abuse
and emotional turmoil.
"You live in two worlds, and you can't
be fully part of either one," he says. "You're not the best athlete you can
be. You're not the best human you can
Nolan hopes Harvey Milk sports will
offer a small refuge from all that. "Why can't we offer the same opportunities
to everyone?" he asks. "When will we do away with our sense of drama. We
have to rise above this for the sake of these
"It's time we in America opened up our
minds and hearts."